Vecna Vs Pennywise: How Will The Mind Flayer's Puppet Fare Against The IT Creature?

Horror fans have been spoilt for choice with two horror icons, IT, aka Pennywise, and Vecna ruling the small screen, respectively, in “IT: Welcome to Derry” and the final season of Netflix’s “Stranger Things.” Bill Skarsgard’s performance as Pennywise in the prequel series of Andy Muschietti’s “IT” movies has accorded the character a legendary status in the horror hall of fame, whereas Jamie Campbell Bower’s portrayal of Vecna has solidified the character’s position amidst figures like Leatherface and Freddie Kruger. Surely, nerds have already speculated who among these characters is stronger, or who would emerge as a victor in a face-off? While the answer apparently feels like a no-brainer, there is more than meets the eye in this particular clash. Let us take a measure of the strengths and weaknesses of these two creatures of nightmare to assess who might dominate in a fantasy battle.

Spoilers Ahead

Vecna: Psychic Monster Commanding His Own Domain

Everything hideous, scary, and otherworldly about Henry Creel stemmed from the hellish world known as Dimension X, aka the Abyss. After getting his hands on a mysterious rock that was stolen by a scientist from Dr. Brenner’s Nevada Experiment, young Henry was transported into the Abyss during the 1950s, and his mind was influenced by the darkness of a monstrous Hive Mind creature later known as the Mind Flayer. Gaining psychokinetic powers and losing touch with his human self, a young Henry committed a series of violent acts, which culminated in the death of his mother and sister. Dr. Brenner exploited Henry to create a generation of psychic test subjects until he was able to get rid of his shackles with El’s help and wreaked havoc by killing the other test subjects. El banished Henry to the Abyss, and this time, while stuck in limbo between the real world and the Abyss, Henry went through a transformation caused by cosmic energies, which turned him into the monstrous Vecna. Aside from wielding immense telekinetic, telepathic, and mind manipulation powers, Vecna can also conjure elaborate mindscapes to trap his victims. Tapping into his victims’ memories and psyche, siphoning psychokinetic energy from his prey, creating gateways across dimensions, and commanding an army of Abyss denizens like Demogorgons, Demobats, and Demodogs, Vecna is a formidable monster who aims to remold the real world to suit his malevolent vision. Vecna’s power gets amplified when he is connected with the Hive Mind of Mind Flayers, which grants him command over all the Abyss’ creations and allows him to remotely sense the world around them. With superhuman physical strength, resilience, and an accelerated healing factor, Vecna is an extremely tough enemy to square off against. 

On paper, Vecna’s diversified abilities might make it seem like he is a near-omnipotent being, especially in his domain—the Abyss. But in reality, Vecna has some glaring weaknesses, which make him seem somewhat overrated. Vecna has not been able to root out the human part within him, and Henry’s most shameful, harrowing childhood memory is Vecna’s biggest weakness and fear. The victims Vecna chooses as his vessels also have the ability to channel his own power to exert control over him and other denizens of the Abyss—which is a humiliating weakness if you think about it. Vecna’s victims can escape his mindscape by holding on to their emotional anchors, which indicates that strong mental resolve can allow someone to escape the monster’s mental hold. With most of Vecna’s strength and weakness highlighted, let’s take a look at his opponent, Stephen King’s timeless creation, ‘IT,’ whose corporeal form is Pennywise the Dancing Clown. 

IT, aka Pennywise: A Veritable Cosmic God

The creature known as IT is classified as a cosmic eldritch deity known as Deadlights, whose creation goes as far back as the inception of the known universe. In Stephen King’s multiverse, Deadlights originated from the other-dimensional space known as the Macroverse. According to the novels, it arrived on Earth millions of years ago, predating the existence of human civilization, and set the foundation of the town Derry. After the arrival of the settlers, the creature began its cycle of 27 years of hibernation followed by a period of feeding on its victims. The true form of Deadlights is incomprehensible to mere mortals; in order to feed on the souls of its victims, IT takes various forms—especially that of Pennywise the Dancing Clown, the performing persona of Robert ‘Bob’ Grey. Feeding on the fears of its victims allows IT to enjoy the hunt, and the creature can shapeshift to any form to strike fear at the hearts of its victims. Coming to the strength part, IT possesses nigh omnipotence and is an ageless immortal who can not be completely obliterated—only his corporeal manifestations can be destroyed. IT has vast telepathic, telekinetic, mind manipulation, and reality warping abilities and can exercise complete control over the minds of its victims. In fact, the reason as to why most of Derry’s horrifying history remains buried in the past is because IT keeps generations of townsfolk lulled by its powers. Unless it enters into a mortal vessel, no physical assault can harm it. 

Despite having such exalted abilities and powers, Pennywise still has some weaknesses, which can curb its influence over others. Maturin the cosmic turtle is a nemesis to IT, and any aspect of the cosmic guardian offers protection against Pennywise’s powers. According to the series’ legend, the meteorite that contained IT and its fragments can repel the influence of the chaos deity. Most importantly, true courage, strong willpower, and overcoming one’s deepest fears give one immunity against IT. Hubris is another one of IT’s weaknesses, which prompts the beast to underestimate its victims and suffer multiple humiliating setbacks. 

Who Wins in a Fight Between Vecna and Pennywise?

A battle between Vecna and Pennywise is going to be purely cerebral, and Vecna will gain an advantage if the battle takes place in locations like the Abyss or the Upside Down. Maturin and the meteor fragments are outside elements, which I will not consider to be effective in combat; also, Maturin, being a righteous cosmic guardian, would never assist a villainous entity like Vecna. True courage, fearlessness, and willpower are three factors that could allow Vecna to pin down Pennywise, and that’s where the game changes on its head. You see, Vecna has not overcome the fear of facing Henry’s haunting memory of committing his first murder, and this will be exploited by Pennywise with his usual sadistic ruthlessness. No matter how strong Vecna’s willpower is, the moment Pennywise senses his insecurities and the truth of Henry’s human self, it will dominate over Vecna’s mind and alter the reality accordingly. There is only one master of fear in this matchup, which Pennywise will prove himself to be by exerting control over Vecna’s psyche. Additionally, Vecna’s mind control powers work both ways, which will allow IT to enter and ravage his mindscape with relative ease. 

This contest could have been summed up by simply stating that an overrated psychic mutant stands no chance against an unkillable cosmic deity—but that would not have provided a thorough assessment of how strong Pennywise really is against a chump like Vecna. Agreed, both of them have been taken down by teenagers, but the difference is Pennywise actually terrorized and preyed on his enemies and can come back in a different avatar, whereas Vecna couldn’t even eliminate the powerless ones and got humiliated by his prime adversaries. It will be a better matchup if ERB decides to make a rap battle featuring both these monsters, like they previously pitted Pennywise against Joker. 

...