Student Of The Year: After Dark Ending Explained: Who Killed Ayesha?

1 day ago

Student Of The Year: After Dark Ending Explained: Who Killed Ayesha?

If you are among those who finds Karan Johar’s obnoxiously superficial, extravagant, vapid teenage romantic drama movie series, “Student of the Year” to be amusing, you’ll probably also like Hotstar’s latest emo-edgy update in the franchise’s first web series adaptation, “Student of the Year: After Dark”. Led by Shanaya Kapoor and a host of young actors, the series progresses as a murder mystery, handling some dark, and often downright ludicrous take on teenage problems – navigating emotional depth of average weekend popcorn entertainers. With some of the comedic elements adding satirical flair, and overall aesthetic matching well with the psychological dread the series wants to convey, “SOTY: After Dark” is somewhat more bearable than its predecessors even though it’s quite a low bar to cross.

Spoilers Ahead

Why Did Aditi Join the Game At St. Teresa?

The series opens with a shocking scene, Aayesha Malik, former child star and the so-called Queen Bee of St. Teresa Heritage School, one of the most prestigious private academic institutions in India, records herself live while sharing a delirious rant while walking alone at the woods , fearing that someone(s) is targeting her and vowing revenge against those who are tormenting her. Something grabs Aayesha’s attention, petrifying her in the process before the recording abruptly ends, and it is revealed the next day that Aayesha has tragically died by drowning in a near frozen lake. The video, and recent information regarding Aayesha quickly gets pushed under the rugs and wiped off of the internet. 

Aayesha’s identical twin sister, Aditi, is polar opposite to her in terms of demeanor and worldview, and the sisters used to share an estranged relationship since last four years before the shocking tragedy brings Aditi and her parents to Barakahali, at St. Teresa. Like Aayesha, Aditi used to be a child star as well, before a tragic incident turned the trajectory of her fate forever. Malik’s parents, Shobha and her husband never found peace in each other’s company, while Shobha tried to use their daughters’ popularity to push them further to stardom, her good for nothing husband mooched off of their children’s earnings. On one occasion during an ad shoot, to take her sister’s mind away from their parents’ bickering, Aayesha encouraged Aditi to engage in some mischievous activities with her – i.e climbing on the light rig and unscrewing the clamps. Aayesha’s actions resulted in the accidental death of a spot boy who was crushed to death under the fallen rig, and the blame of the incident was shifted completely on Aditi. A remorseful Aayesha didn’t defend her sister by acting selfishly, and an aggrieved Aditi wishes death upon her. After that traumatic incident, the Malik couple separated, with Shobha shaping up Aayesha’s life the way she wanted, while her scummy husband took Aditi away and poisoned her mind against her mother and sister by making her believe that they didn’t care about her. 

However, Aditi longed to make amends with her sister one day, and having that chance taken away from him, her world came tumbling down. As the local authorities wrapped up the case very quickly, without even performing an autopsy of the corpse which hasn’t yet thawed, a rugged, observant Aditi assumes foul play by looking at the telltale signs on the corpse which indicate Aayesha’s death was anything but accidental. With Shobha’s help, Aditi almost coerces newly appointed Dean Jatin to have her admitted in the school as she wants to investigate the death of her sister.  Aditi gets acquainted with Aayesha’s close circle, her boyfriend, rich and toxic Sid Saraiya, jilted one sided lover, Rehaan Rizvi, annoyingly hyperactive, bumbling bestie Tara Barman and her closeted gay boyfriend Jay-D, and rival figure, Smriti Bisht aka Babydoll. All the friends are also participating in a secretive game tournament called ‘Student of the Year’, which apparently ensures the winner, irrespective of their background or academic performance, wins enough wealth and fame to become one of the most influential figures of the society. Aditi learns that Aayesha was one of the participants of the game, and given the highly competitive nature of it, along with the involvement of the shady, all-powerful controller, Aditi deduces the only way to get answers is to participate in the game. Shobha, who wants Aditi not to risk her life while investigating the truth, discourages her from undertaking such dangerous ordeals, but a driven Aditi remains determined to seek justice for her sister. 

What Were the Motives of Aayesha’s Friends?

As Aditi plays the games and gets to know the members of Aayesha’s friends group a bit better, she realizes behind the fake sympathies, all of them had motives which are strong enough to have Aditi murdered. Sid not only comes from a reputed, influential family, his elder brother, Ranvijay and their father, played by Neeraj Kabi, both toxic and abusive guardian figures, are past winners of the tournament.  As an adopted son of Mr. Saraiya, Sid always feels the burden to win the tournament at any cost. Ranvijay actively pushes him to take sleeping pills, performance enhancers, and coerces him to avoid all the distractions like relationships, friendships. Sid physically abused Aayesha, and upon learning this, Aditi delivers some much deserved beatdown on him even though he manages to evade the repercussions of his actions. Tara is extremely obsessed with becoming popular, is quite insensitive and probably had a row with Aayesha in the recent past. Babydoll, who keeps a hard-boiled, rough and tough persona as a front, is revealed to be holding a grudge against Aayesha for how she cruelly ridiculed her humble belongings by exposing her to social media. Rehaan appears to be a decent individual, but as Aditi probes further and manages to find Aayesha’s phone, she finds out like the rest of his classmates, he too is hiding crucial details about the night Aayesha died. Building trust and lack of it creates a strange, uncertain dynamic between Aayesha’s friends group and Aditi, while the unseen gamemaster monitors Aditi’s moves and tries to keep her in check.  

On one occasion, a desperate Aditi decides to abduct all the members of the friends group in a cabin in the woods and persuade them to spill the beans. However, it turns out that even though they kept the true details of the day a secret from Aditi, they didn’t murder Aayesha. Surveillance footage reveals Aayesha lost her life while trying to complete the qualifier round of the tournament by fetching a collectible from the frozen lake. 

However, Aayesha and Rehaan manage to deduce there were signs of poisoning in Aayesha’s corpse, something which the autopsy report of the local authorities completely overlooks. Aayesha’s parents are informed by Dean Jatin to take her back home after the abduction fiasco, and following a heated argument with her parents, Aayesha is shocked to learn that her father villainized their mother, Shobha, and spent all their earnings in gambling. Refusing to remain as her father’s puppet any longer, Aayesha reconciles with Shobha, and with her help along with the friends group, she manages to fetch the real autopsy report which makes Dean Jatin appear as the culprit in question. Given he previously taunted Aditi for prying too much and having assumed the life of her sister by taking advantage of the tragedy, it appears he is the gamemaster in question who is trying to keep things under the wraps. It should be mentioned that following her win in the second round against Babydoll, Aditi becomes the finalist of the game tournament along with Jay-D, Tara and Sid. It should be mentioned that Sid is able to participate despite disqualification because Mr. Saraiya is revealed to be the game master. 

During Aayesha and Dean D’Souza’s memorial service, hosted by Mr. Saraiya, Sid has a nervous breakdown and shows torn pieces of Aayesha’s autopsy report to Ranvijay which reveals she had high doses of sleeping meds in her system. Sid fears that in his deluded state of mind either he killed her on that fateful night, or Ranvijay must have eliminated her to keep ‘distractions’ away. The fact that Ranvijay acknowledges the self recorded video and surveillance footage of Aayesha to be fake videos shared to hide the truth, make it seem the Saraiyas have used their power to cover up Aayesha’s murder. On the other hand, Rehaan confesses to Aditi that he became aware that Dean D’Souza and Aayesha’s death might be connected, and Tara confesses on her own that she and Aayesha used the persona of a certain Meeta to catfish Dean D’Souza, who might have took his own life in shame. Tara believes Aayesha did the same after her reputation came into jeopardy in light of such shocking revelation surfacing.

Who Killed Aayesha?

However, the truth is much more sinister, about which Aditi learns while taking part in the final game, which is a strange hypnosis psychic-trap challenge. As it turns out, Tara is the culprit who pushed D’¢§÷ Dean D’Souza’s daughter, who has spent her childhood craving for paternal affection after her father abandoned their family to adhere to his duties towards St. Teresa. Years later, when Tara was able to get admitted to the prestigious institution by her own merit, she had hoped her father would acknowledge and accept her. However, much to her dismay, D’Souza refused to acknowledge her and threatened to take away her scholarship if she ever dared to reveal their filial relationship in public. 

An anguished Tara hatched upon a plan to subject her father to similar heartbreak by conjuring up this fake identity of a middle aged woman named Meeta, and with Aayesha’s help, catfished her own father. While Aayesha initially considered this to be a funny prank, she distanced herself from Tara after learning that Tara was using this love trap to squeeze expensive gifts, money out of him. Tara exacted revenge for paternal abandonment by revealing the truth to D’Souza, and blackmailed him by threatening to expose him to the school faculty. In utter shame, D’Souza committed suicide by having his own car exhaust blocked. 

Later, Aayesha confronted Tara about her role in shattering D’Souza’s will to live, and made the mistake of threatening to expose her. Tara, who is a psychopath who enjoyed controlling over her father’s life and emotions, saw no fault of her own, and deemed Aayesha’s warning as an affront. Lying about eventually revealing the truth, she drugged Tara by fetching Sid’s sleeping pills with Jay-D’s help, and drowned her to death in the near frozen lake. Babydoll had warned Aditi about Aayesha’s sleeping pill overdose condition which she had learned by overheating the conversation between Sid and Ranvijay. During the final game, Aditi confronts Tara, who confesses to her crimes without remorse, and lunges on Aditi to finish her as well. Aditi is saved by Sid’s assistance, who decides to quit the game for good in an act of defiance against his manipulative, abusive father. Before Aditi and rest of the participants can quit as well, Tara manages to win the final round by grabbing onto the winner’s trophy, leaving their fate in question as gamemaster Mr. Saraiya’s operatives enter the arena. As a winner, Tara will probably be able to use her power and influence to cover up her crime, and rewrite the narrative as she pleases. The first season of “SOTY: After Dark” ends on a cliff-hanger, without providing definitive answers whether Aditi will be able to bring Aayesha’s killer, Tara, to justice. 

...

Read the fullstory

It's better on the More. News app

✅ It’s fast

✅ It’s easy to use

✅ It’s free

Start using More.
More. from Film Fugitives ⬇️
news-stack-on-news-image

Why read with More?

app_description